Service was great, we sail to S. Bass Island at least three times per year, and Hooligan's is one of our must hit spots. The skipper likes the Guinness but there are plenty of options for the rest of the crew. As far as Put-in-Bay it is concerned this is one of the cleaner, nicer decor, quality food options that is right downtown.
Loved this place! Irish decor was so fun to look at and the food was amazing! I got the Piggy Melt, a cheese toastie with mac and cheese, pulled pork, and slaw, which was very good! They also had the freshest guinness I've had in a long time, poured perfectly.
AMAZING service! We didn't really eat much because we were there to drink. Our servers were super cool, both from Ireland and fun, fun, fun!!! It rained all day, but we sat on the covered patio and had a great time.